Home / Buffalo / Custom Cookies and Cakes by Karen

Custom Cookies and Cakes by Karen

This listing isn’t verified yet. The details below come from public sources and may be out of date, so check with the baker before you order.

North Tonawanda, NY

Custom Cookies and Cakes by Karen is a home bakery in North Tonawanda, NY making decorated sugar cookies, custom cakes and cupcakes.

Decorated cookiesCustom cakesCupcakes
Message

Menu

Menu unavailable. Custom Cookies and Cakes by Karen hasn’t shared their menu on Small Baker yet, so check their order page for what’s baking this week.

Is this your bakery? Claim your listing to add your menu, prices and pickup days. Locals are looking.

Reviews

No reviews yet. Bought from Custom Cookies and Cakes by Karen? Be the first to say how it went.

Write a review

Reviews come from signed-in Small Baker members and are checked for spam before they appear. We never remove a review for being negative.

Message Custom Cookies and Cakes by Karen

Ask about an order, a custom cake or pickup times.

Write a message

Instagram: @customcookiesandcakesbykaren

Listing details from public sources, last checked October 2026. Closed, moved or wrong? Tell us.

More home bakeries in Buffalo

See all 49 Buffalo bakeries →