Baking With The Brennan Family
Valley Cottage, NY
Home / New York / The Uncommon Cookie
The Uncommon Cookie
This listing isn’t verified yet. The details below come from public sources and may be out of date, so check with the baker before you order.
Malverne, NY
The Uncommon Cookie is a home bakery in Malverne, NY making cookies, cupcakes and decorated sugar cookies.
Reviews
No reviews yet. Bought from The Uncommon Cookie? Be the first to say how it went.
Reviews come from signed-in Small Baker members and are checked for spam before they appear. We never remove a review for being negative.
Message The Uncommon Cookie
Ask about an order, a custom cake or pickup times.
Write a message
Website: theuncommoncookie.com
Listing details from public sources, last checked October 2026. Closed, moved or wrong? Tell us.
More home bakeries in New York
Brookside Cottage Bakery
Harriman, NY
ClaraJane's Cakes
Staten Island, NY
Cookies By The Coop
Lake Carmel, NY
Dulcerella
Nassau County, NY
Four Corners Co
Queens, NY